On Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Gaza and the double standards of selective outrage.
Watch the video: [Embed the full video here]
I’ve had enough of selective outrage.
The latest escalation involving Saudi Arabia and Yemen has once again brought civilian casualties and regional security into the headlines. Any loss of civilian life is a tragedy, and I have no desire to see ordinary people suffer.
But there is a question I want people to answer honestly.
Where was this same level of concern when Yemen was enduring years of conflict, bombardment, hunger and the destruction of essential infrastructure?
According to the UN Yemen Country Team’s 2021 annual report, the conflict had caused more than 377,000 deaths by the end of 2021, including both direct and indirect deaths. Millions of Yemenis needed humanitarian assistance, and the country’s essential services had been devastated.
Those figures are not an excuse to dismiss the deaths of civilians in Saudi Arabia. They are a reminder that Yemen’s suffering must not be forgotten whenever the political focus shifts elsewhere.
Civilian lives cannot matter only when it suits us
My argument is not that one civilian’s death matters less than another’s. It is that the same principles must apply to everyone.
If we condemn attacks that kill civilians in Saudi Arabia, we must also be willing to examine the record of the Saudi-led military intervention in Yemen and the humanitarian consequences of that conflict.
We cannot demand that people look at one tragedy while refusing to look at another.
Nor should criticism of a government be confused with hostility towards its people. Ordinary Yemenis and ordinary Saudis deserve security, dignity and a future without war.
What does Muslim solidarity actually mean?
I also want to ask a difficult question about the language of Muslim solidarity.
When people invoke the suffering of Muslims, that concern should extend to Yemenis as well as Palestinians and Saudis. It should not become a political slogan that is applied to one group and withheld from another.
The war in Gaza has made questions about regional alliances, trade routes and the policies of Middle Eastern governments even more important. Those policies deserve serious scrutiny, including the extent to which they have helped or hindered efforts to support Palestinians.
My criticism of Saudi and Emirati leadership is rooted in those political questions. The evidence for specific allegations must be examined carefully, but no government should be exempt from accountability.
The way forward
The people of Yemen have endured far too much. They need humanitarian assistance, protection for civilians and a political settlement that offers a durable end to the conflict.
Escalation will not make ordinary Yemenis safer. Nor will selective outrage bring justice to the victims of this war.
I want the suffering of Yemen to be recognised, the record of those responsible to be examined, and the same principles of humanity to be applied across the region.
If we believe civilian lives matter, then they must all matter.
That is the argument I make in this video. Watch it, consider the evidence, and tell me where you disagree.









